Calls

Should an auto repair shop use a phone tree?

Short answer: Usually not during open hours. A driver whose car will not start or is making a noise wants a person who can say when it can come in. Every menu option is another chance to hang up and call the next shop. If the shop truly needs routing, keep the menu to one or two choices, let new customers reach a person first, and save the longer menu for after hours.

Key takeaways
  1. 1During open hours, a person beats a menu for new callers.
  2. 2Every extra option is another chance for a driver to hang up.
  3. 3If you need routing, keep it to one or two choices and send new customers to a person first.
  4. 4A menu can help after hours, for parts vendors, and for shops with more than one location.
  5. 5Call your own line from a cell phone and time how long it takes to reach someone.

Usually no: a person beats a menu during open hours

Most auto repair shops should not run a phone tree while the shop is open. The driver on the other end usually has a car problem right now. They want to know if you can look at it and when they can bring it in. A recording that lists options makes them wait before anyone can answer that.

Many of those drivers are calling a few shops in a row. The one that picks up and helps them first often gets the job. The missing calls guide lists a long phone menu as one of the common places shops lose callers. This article goes deeper on that one choice.

What a phone tree costs a repair shop

A phone tree costs a repair shop callers who hang up before they reach anyone. Every option the caller has to hear is a few more seconds of waiting. A driver on the side of the road, or standing in a parking lot with a dead battery, does not want to press one for service, two for parts, and three for hours.

Some of them hang up and try the next shop. You never know they called unless someone checks the call log. That is the hidden part. The menu feels tidy from inside the shop, but the lost calls do not show up anywhere unless you look for them.

When a short phone tree can make sense

A short phone tree can make sense when the shop gets a lot of calls that are not customers. Parts vendors, sales calls, and billing questions can tie up the counter. A shop with more than one location, or one with a separate tire or fleet desk, may also need some routing so calls land with the right person.

After hours is another fair use. When nobody is in the building, a short menu can point callers to leave a message, check on a car, or find the address. The answering service guide covers when a live service makes more sense than a recording for those hours.

How to keep a phone menu short and simple

If you keep a menu, keep it to one or two choices and put new customers first. Start the greeting with the shop name, then the first option should reach a person who can book work. Put vendors or billing after that, or move them to a separate number.

Do not read the hours, the address, and a sales message before the options. Those can go on your Google listing and your website. If someone presses nothing, the call should still ring the front counter, not drop into voicemail. Keep the wording plain enough that a stressed driver gets it on the first listen.

Who should be on the other end

A phone tree only helps if the person it sends callers to actually answers. Pick who owns the phone during open hours and who covers when they are busy. The who should answer the phone guide walks through that choice.

If calls ring the counter while the one person there is with a customer, the menu just moves the missed call one step later. Fix coverage first. Then decide if any routing is still needed.

Test your own line like a new customer

The simplest way to judge your phone tree is to call it yourself. Use a cell phone, call the main number the way a new customer would, and time how long it takes to reach a person. Try a busy morning, lunch, and the last hour of the day.

Listen for the places you would hang up. Then call after hours and check that the voicemail greeting is short and the box is not full. Cut options until reaching someone feels quick. Then check the call log every week to see how many callers still hang up before anyone answers.

Questions shop owners ask

Should an auto repair shop use a phone tree?

Usually not while the shop is open. Most people calling a repair shop have a car problem and want to know when they can bring it in. A menu makes them wait before they reach anyone who can answer that, and some will hang up and call the next shop on the list. If the shop needs some routing, keep it to one or two choices and make sure a new customer reaches a person first.

How many options should an auto repair shop phone menu have?

As few as possible. One or two choices is plenty for most shops. Every option a caller has to listen to adds time before they hear a person, and a driver standing next to a broken car is not patient. If you find yourself adding a third or fourth option, ask whether those callers could simply be handled by whoever answers, or reached through a separate number or a text.

What should the first option on a repair shop phone tree be?

The first option should reach a person who can book work. New and returning customers calling about their car are the calls that pay the bills, so they should never have to wait through the parts or billing options first. Say it plainly at the top, something like press one to schedule service or check on your car, and make sure that option rings the front counter, not a voicemail box.

Does a phone tree make a small shop sound more professional?

Not to most drivers. A long menu can make a small shop sound like a big office, but people calling a repair shop are usually not judging how polished the greeting sounds. They want to know if you can fix the car and when. A friendly person who answers by the shop name and asks how they can help sounds more professional than any recording.

Can a phone tree help with parts vendors and sales calls?

It can, and that is one of the few places it helps. Parts runners, vendors, and sales calls can eat time at the counter. A simple option for vendors, or a separate line you give only to vendors, keeps those calls from tying up the person who books customer work. Just do not make customers listen to vendor options before they reach someone.

How do I test my shop's phone menu?

Call your own number from a cell phone, the way a new customer would, at a few different times of day. Time how long it takes to reach a real person, and note every place you would be tempted to hang up. Try it after hours too, and make sure the voicemail box is not full. If reaching someone takes too long, cut options until it does not.

FREE Growth Session

See what’s working, and what isn’t.

Book a FREE Growth Session with Isaac and Alyssa. They audit your shop first. You keep the audit either way.

Isaac and Alyssa Donnelson